IDReaper's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[NamiZuz[Dj eXite] xD]

I am a minimalist fan.

The volume on your percussion was a little low and I wish it was longer, but otherwise I have no complaints. Great loop execution.

eXite responds:

Thanks, I'll make the next one Longer :D

[DJ Comet-Oh No Remix]

Do I hear?

That synth from your superhero remix? Lol either way it sounds nice. The audio does take a while to really hit its groove but overall it turned out great. Nice remix.

TheComet responds:

Close to it, I edited the synth from Oh No for Superhero Remix a few times, but more instruments were edits of Rapture's (sans-effects)

[Summer Rain]

Pleasant sound.

Not bad, pretty nice song. However, there are some(dare I say it?) voice imperfections, mostly on the low notes. Guitar playing was pretty good although I though the palm mutes sounded a little off. Lol at the whistling, that was great xD. Still despite some quirks, good song.

8/10
4/5
NOICE!

IDR

writtenkits responds:

Thanks for your criticism. When your being rushed in a studio, while double recording vocals, voice imperfections tend to happen. But I also need to work more on my singing. Appreciate the imput mang!

[A Broken Man]

Decent

Some parts sounds kinda, well, off though. The violin in the first part sounded kinda wierd. Also the audio feels a little bare. I like the piano quite a bit in the second part and though. In my opinion the last two movements were the best. It coud use some polishing up though. Keep at it :)

IDR

crazyguy832 responds:

First off, thanks for the review.

Second... yeah, I figured at least a couple people won't of liked this because of the violin in the first part. One too many dissonant chords? Aye, I suppose so. Definetely agree I could have done that better, but whenever I listen to it I can't tell what I should change (as, to my ears, it sounds good, even though I know it theoretically shouldn't... heh... been playing piano way too long, ears have gotten used to dissonant chords working in music, suppose I need a bit more practice with them, however).

XD

Ah, well, I suppose I'll just have to leave it at that. Thanks for the comments!

^_^

[SG - Popcorn Remix]

Pretty Good.

Got pretty rpetitive tho. I know the original is like that but still, a little to repetitive. Sound quality is top nitch tho, so it manages to remain enjoyable.

Testicle responds:

Cheers for the review!

-Saul

[{BD} Ravelocity]

I can honestly say

I don't see much really wrong with this song. The melody is great and the sounds balance well. The transitions were a little underwhelming though, since it didnt change to much. But that is all I can really find that annoys me. Great track.

RB6ELITE responds:

thanks alot man...i'd been waiting for a review on this song (put it up like in november)

[B-1]

I would say happy...

What you have here is calm and peaceful music. Kinda like happy ending stuff. You know, bitter sweet, right? Hope I'm not confusing you. But the point is, it turned out great. Ha I thought Zelda too xD.

linkbryan1126 responds:

where does everyone keep getting zelda from?!?

anyway, thats the exact sound i was going for, bitter sweet, calm and happy, good, but a little sad

[HM - Do your Best! - LR08]

Pleasant Sounding.

Nice take on a Harvest Moon song. All of the instruments balance well, and the audio flows together seamlessly. The Only things I can fault are the shortness(yeah I know it's a VG loop tho) and the fact that it doesn't loop too well.

8/10
4/5

"Don't say anything Timmy-Tom! The secret will keep you alive!"
Quote from Blockhead. Just thought it could be inspiration or something lol :)

littlerampage08 responds:

I'm not quite ready to expand on songs like this yet, but look at me in the future. I'll be planning to make little loops like this into long things. I'm not quite there yet, I got a few in the making, but I'm not quite ready to show NG.
Thanks for the review!

[Holy Pirate Crusaders]

G'DAMN!

Slow start, then it hits you, BLAM out of nowhere. An incredible epic song that deserves its title.

Erectronik responds:

Aye aye, me loves doing musics like this!

LP

[New Generation (NG)]

Neat

That is a lot of genres O.O I love how everything is streamed together seamlessly. I agree with the first poster however that the trance work at the end could use some, well, work. Otherwise this is a quality track with great progression.

Developer responds:

Looks like I have to remove the trance ending. :)
I have no experience in writing trance, so I`ll mb read more about it and come back to this track later.